| Where the colour sits | Pigment carried in water soaks down into the cotton and dries inside the fibre. | An opaque ink is pushed through a screen and cured with heat, leaving a flexible film sitting on top of the weave. | Water-based ink is sprayed by an inkjet head straight onto the cloth, usually over a white underbase when the garment is dark. | A pre-made film is cut or printed, then bonded onto the outside of the garment with heat and pressure. It lies over the cloth rather than in it. | Not a print at all. Thread is stitched through the cloth, or a short pile is bonded to it. The colour is a physical body sitting proud of the surface. |
|---|
| What a fingertip finds | Almost nothing. Run a finger across the boundary and you will not find an edge — the printed area and the bare cloth are level with each other. | A distinct rubbery patch with a measurable thickness. The fingertip finds the edge and can trace the whole outline of the design. | Very little on light cloth. On dark cloth there is a faint, thin skin where the white underbase sits, softer and thinner than a screen-printed layer. | A sheet. The fingertip catches on a clear step at the boundary, and the whole area moves as one piece rather than with the weave. | Obvious relief. Either hard glossy thread with a direction to it, or a soft dense pile that bends under the finger like suede and shows the mark. |
|---|
| Under raking light | Individual threads still visible straight through the colour | A slight sheen that changes as you tilt the garment | Photographic detail and smooth gradients that a screen would struggle with | A continuous boundary, often a rectangle or a cut outline around the artwork | Individual thread passes catching light one by one |
|---|
| Wash cycles, as a range | 40–80 | 25–60 | 20–50 | 10–35 | 50–120 |
|---|
| How it ends | It fades. It does not crack and it does not lift, because there is no layer to crack or lift. | It crazes into a network of fine cracks, and flakes lift from the edges of those cracks. Once the layer has fractured the fracture is permanent. | It goes chalky and pale, mostly because the fabric fuzzes up over the image. The pigment that is still in the fibre is not coming back to the surface. | A corner or an edge lifts, then the lift travels. Sometimes the film also cracks across itself. Neither the lift nor the crack can be pressed back. | A pulled loop, a distorted block, or crushed pile. A pulled thread can sometimes be eased back by hand but the distortion in the cloth stays. |
|---|
| Where it makes sense | Solid colours and simple artwork on light cotton, in runs large enough to justify making a screen. | Opaque colour on dark cloth, and any design that has to stay bright rather than sink into the fabric. | Full-colour and photographic artwork, and short runs where cutting screens for every colour would not be possible at all. | Short runs, one-offs, names and numbers, and full-colour images on dark cloth. For a great deal of printed clothing this is the only way it gets made at all. | Small marks, logos and lettering on heavier cloth, and anywhere the texture itself is the point. |
|---|